top of page
Writer's pictureRica Vergara Beck

New York: Renting vs. Buying for Expats and Foreigners


As an expat and international real estate consultant who lived in New York City for nine years, I understand the unique challenges and opportunities that come with navigating the NYC housing market. Here’s a guide to help you decide whether to rent or buy a home in this bustling metropolis, tailored specifically for expats and foreigners.



The Appeal of Renting in NYC


For expats, renting is often the go-to option, particularly for those unfamiliar with NYC's fast-paced real estate market. Renting offers flexibility, which is beneficial if your stay in NYC is temporary or if you're uncertain about your long-term plans.


1. Low Initial Costs: Renting requires a security deposit (usually one month’s rent) and possibly a broker's fee. In contrast, buying requires a substantial down payment (typically 20% of the property price) and closing costs.

   

2. Flexibility: Lease terms usually range from one to two years, allowing for easier relocation if your job or lifestyle changes. 

   

3. Market Uncertainty: Renting shields you from the unpredictability of property values and market fluctuations. According to PropertyClub, when market conditions are volatile, renting can be a safer, more stable option.


The Case for Buying in NYC


While renting offers flexibility, buying a home in NYC may be more financially advantageous in the long run, particularly if you plan to stay for a considerable period.


1. Asset Building: Purchasing property is an investment. Over years, you build equity, which can be financially rewarding if the property value appreciates.

   

2. Stable Monthly Payments: Mortgages often have fixed rates, which means monthly payments stay consistent, unlike rent which can increase annually.


3. Personalization: Owning allows for greater freedom in renovations and personalizations without the need for landlord approval.


Price-to-Rent Ratio


A critical element in making this decision is understanding the price-to-rent ratio, which measures the relative affordability of renting versus buying. It's calculated by dividing the median home price by the median annual rent.


- Price-to-Rent Ratio < 15: Generally, buying is more advantageous.

- Price-to-Rent Ratio 15-20: The decision can go either way.

- Price-to-Rent Ratio > 20: Renting is typically more favorable.


Curbed’s 2019 article highlights that NYC's price-to-rent ratio often exceeds 20, indicating that for many, renting is the more affordable option. However as of March 2023, Arrived indicates that NYC;s price-to-rent ratio decreased to 13.2, which for buying is a more favorable.


Considerations for Foreign Buyers


As a foreigner, there are additional factors to consider:


1. Financing: Securing a mortgage can be challenging as non-residents often face higher interest rates and may need larger down payments.

   

2. Legal and Tax Implications: Understanding the legal and tax ramifications of owning property in the US is crucial. Consulting with a local real estate attorney can provide clarity on these issues.


Conclusion


Choosing whether to rent or buy in NYC is highly personal and dependent on your circumstances. As an expat, renting may offer the flexibility you need, but if your long-term plans include staying in NYC, buying could be a sound investment. Always consider market conditions, financial readiness, and future plans when making this significant decision.



 

References:

  • PropertyClub: Renting Versus Buying a Home in NYC: How to Decide

  • Curbed NY: Should You Rent or Buy a Home?

  • Arrived,: What Is Price-To-Rent Ratio in Real Estate Investing?

  • Investopedia: Price-to-Rent Ratio


 

Disclaimer


The information provided on this website is for informational purposes only and should not be regarded as definitive real estate advice. Real estate markets and regulations are subject to change, and while we aim for accuracy, the content may not reflect the most current developments. The insights shared represent opinions and should not be deemed absolute. Any referrals made to our network of experts are intended for convenience and should be complemented with legal advice. By using this website, you agree that any reliance on the provided information is at your own risk.


Comentários


bottom of page